Amnesty Is 1 Signature From a Vote & Cornyn Blocks Trump's Judge | Phil Kerpen & Robert McNeily
The Jenny Beth ShowNovember 19, 2026x
161
01:04:0058.67 MB

Amnesty Is 1 Signature From a Vote & Cornyn Blocks Trump's Judge | Phil Kerpen & Robert McNeily

Guest: Phil Kerpen, president of American Commitment, a national free market advocacy group that works on fiscal, economic, and regulatory issues and writes to Congress, regulatory agencies, and governors on the policy fights where an engaged citizen can make a difference.

 

Guest host: Robert McNeily, Director of Broadcasting and Grassroots Engagement at Tea Party Patriots Action, in for Jenny Beth Martin.

 

Key topics:

• Congressman Robert Garcia's 12 letters to President Trump's sons, his son-in-law, the Vice President, and White House staff, and the White House answer that a request from the minority side triggers no obligation

• The 1957 Supreme Court line that Congress has no power "to expose for the sake of exposure," and the question for every chairman: what law are you writing?

• President Trump, Xi Jinping, and Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen: the joint declaration, Beijing's claim about Taiwan, and whether a nuclear agreement would ever go to the Senate as a treaty

• The China trade truce that runs out January 10 and what American farmers should watch for

• Senator John Cornyn withholding his blue slip on T. Elliot Gaiser, President Trump's nominee for a federal judgeship in Dallas

• Senate Majority Leader John Thune's numbers: 59 judges confirmed, four more filed, and about 100 nominees before January 3

• The permitting bill, and why Kerpen sees good friends on both sides of it

• The $350 billion defense bill and why Kerpen says it has to be paid for

• Why Republicans lost on the cost of living: Kerpen on oil, diesel, and six months of prices rising faster than incomes

• The discharge petition for the American Dream and Promise Act: 217 signatures, one short

• Senator Mike Lee's answer, "Amnesty, never," and the poll showing 76.5 percent of likely voters agree

• The 1986 amnesty and the border enforcement that never came

• Senator Bernie Sanders' Medicare for All bill and what it does to Medicare and to private coverage

• Senator Ron Johnson calling Social Security "a legal Ponzi scheme," and Kerpen on why the trust fund is an accounting fiction

• The new federal scholarship tax credit and the 19 states whose governors have not opted in

 

Timestamps:

00:00 — Cold open: Garcia's 12 letters

00:49 — The letters, the White House answer, and "what law are you writing?"

01:40 — President Trump, Xi Jinping, and Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen

02:57 — Phil Kerpen and the hour ahead

03:53 — Oversight, or exposure for its own sake?

05:34 — November 19 in history: Reagan and Gorbachev, and Gettysburg

07:05 — 1957: no power "to expose for the sake of exposure"

08:41 — Mark Levin on Garcia's list

09:22 — The Shenzhen summit and President Trump's opening remarks

11:17 — Phil Kerpen: what America gets at the table

12:41 — Beijing's Taiwan claim

14:36 — Could a nuclear deal get through the Senate?

15:53 — The China trade truce and American farmers

17:41 — Senator Cornyn blocks President Trump's judge in Texas

19:09 — Blue slips: should the Senate move without him?

20:33 — 59 judges confirmed, and 100 nominees before January 3

21:37 — The permitting bill

24:41 — The $350 billion defense bill

26:58 — Why Republicans lost on the cost of living

31:27 — What the Senate has to finish before January 3

32:39 — Your assignment: the Post-Election Supporter Survey

33:23 — Amnesty is one signature from a House vote

35:01 — Senator Mike Lee: "Amnesty, never," and what voters say

40:19 — Secretary Mullin at the House hearing

40:48 — 1986: the amnesty came, the enforcement never did

42:20 — House Democrats nominate Hakeem Jeffries for Speaker

43:08 — Bernie Sanders and Medicare for All

48:39 — Sanders lays out his plan, and Tom Emmer's answer

49:16 — Medicare at 55, and what happens to your plan at work

50:23 — Senator Ron Johnson on Social Security

52:37 — Kerpen: the trust fund is an accounting fiction

57:11 — How conservatives should talk about Social Security

58:18 — American Commitment and the scholarship tax credit

01:00:21 — The survey, one more time

01:01:13 — This day in history, and the close

 

Links mentioned:

teapartypatriots.org (Post-Election Supporter Survey)

jennybethshow.com

[00:00:00] With all the threats of impeachments, investigations and continued Democrat lawfare, Congressman Robert Garcia of California has promised us with this quote, this is just the beginning. He can't issue a single subpoena for another 45 days, but on Wednesday he sent 12 letters anyway to President Trump's son, Don Jr. and Eric Trump, his son-in-law Jared Kushner, the Vice President and the White House Chief of Staff.

[00:00:27] Welcome to The Jenny Beth Show. I'm Robert McNeily in for Jenny Beth Martin. Welcome to The Jenny Beth Show. Garcia is the Democrat who will chair the House Oversight Committee come January 3rd.

[00:00:54] Now his letters tell Donald Trump Jr. and Eric Trump, Jared Kushner, Stephen Miller, Susie Wiles, Vice President Vance, Attorney General Blanche and others to preserve their records. Now the White House answered the same afternoon, a request from the minority side does not trigger any obligation. So here's the million dollar question we'll get every time a subpoena goes out in January.

[00:01:20] Congress has the power to investigate so it can ultimately write laws. So Mr. Chairman, what potential bills do you or do these investigations pertain to? Are you simply trying to quote unquote get Trump as Tish James promised us in New York State? And news from over overnight and it's on your screen here. President Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin sat on the table in Shenzhen, China,

[00:01:50] in the first ever trilateral meeting of the three leaders. Now this morning, the White House published the joint declaration they issued following the meeting. They agreed to hold a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks. They agreed that the International Criminal Court must not abuse its jurisdiction. And they called for reforming the United Nations. They also pledged to increase the production and supply of refined petroleum products.

[00:02:16] But notably absent from the declaration, any mention of Iran, Ukraine, Taiwan or trade issues. But those were discussed separately by the leaders. But they did not make it into the joint statement. Prior to that trilateral meeting, President Trump sitting down with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin on separate meetings before this trilateral summit.

[00:02:42] So what will ultimately happen next as world leaders wrap up the 2026 Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation Leaders Meeting, otherwise known as APEC, that's a biannual conference. We have Phil Kirpin with us for the whole hour. Phil is the president of American Commitment. So we'll take on Garcia's letters and Shenzhen.

[00:03:06] Then the Senate Republican who just blocked President Trump's judge and judicial nominee request in the great state of Texas. Also, the amnesty petition that is one signature short. Bernie Sanders and Medicare for all. It's a socialist dreamland for Bernie. Senator Johnson on Social Security and Congresswoman Anna Polina Luna. Her plan to bar dual citizens from Congress, a big issue. I was speaking to a friend about that earlier this week.

[00:03:36] Phil Kirpin, thank you so much for joining me today. Seems to be some audio with Phil's on our side. We'll get that fixed for you there. But as we're going to talk about today, Garcia's release of 12 letters and the list, including President Trump's sons, a former ambassador,

[00:04:03] and the head of a charity that raised money for the White House ballroom. These letters are really quite disturbing because we have to ask ourselves the question, is Congress using its specific authority of oversight or is it actually interfering with the American people? You, the people who have put people into power in order to serve us here in the United States.

[00:04:32] The president is duly elected through the Electoral College by the people. Article 2 power grants him these abilities to appoint and put people into place that can make the whole of government happen from an executive branch side. But we saw with Pencil Neck Schiff out in California just a few years ago,

[00:04:58] how all of this Russia, Russia, Russiagate and this lawfare really unfolded before our eyes in the first term and how disturbing that can be for people as we want our government to function. It's very clear what happened in this election. 2026 was about affordability, gas prices, really bringing down the entire cost of living for the American people.

[00:05:24] But Democrats now revealing their hand and that the next two years could potentially be all about investigations. As we'll highlight throughout this show today, November 19th is a big day in history because President Trump having that first trilateral meeting with adversaries overseas, with Vladimir Putin and with Xi Jinping of China.

[00:05:49] It was on this very day in 1985 that President Reagan first sat down with Mikhail Gorbachev to talk denuclearization and how fitting all these years later that we now have a Chinese Communist Party threat to the whole world. Once the threat that Russia was in the Soviet Union, we're watching that very closely.

[00:06:16] And also on this day, all those years ago, the Gettysburg address where Abraham Lincoln spoke for only two minutes. So short that they could barely get a picture at the end of it. Back in those times, it took some time to capture that picture. Not everyone was carrying around an iPhone as they are today. And he talked of a government of the people. By the people, for the people shall not perish from the earth.

[00:06:46] So what does that mean in the grand scheme of things? What does that mean in the long run for us here in America as we try to keep that same form of Republican government over the course of 250 years? Something we're celebrating now. In 1957, the Supreme Court said Congress has no power to expose for the sake of exposure.

[00:07:12] Chief Justice Earl Warren wrote, writing the majority opinion, We have no doubt that there is no congressional power to expose for the sake of exposure. The public is, of course, entitled to be informed concerning the workings of its government. It cannot be inflated into a general power to expose where the predominant result

[00:07:39] can only be an invasion of the private rights of individuals. So as we break that all down, the real question is whether a committee has a real legislative purpose in order to, again, attack the Article II branches of government. And that's why White House counsel Will Scharf wrote that requests from a ranking member doesn't trigger any obligation.

[00:08:05] And he pointed out that the Biden White House took the very same position back in 2022. So the question is, should the people on Robert Garcia's list, again, he's not the chairman yet. He's just throwing shade at the administration, simply as a congressman from California, really force everyone to preserve everything anyway.

[00:08:30] Perhaps it is good legal advice and counsel for the White House to do that because we know what's coming. They've been very clear about that ever since Election Day. Now, Mark Levin reading Garcia's list on the radio last night, and here's what he said to quote the great one. I don't see anything in here about affordability, not a damn thing. That's what Democrats ran on this fall. It was about the cost of living.

[00:08:58] And now they're doing otherwise. So, well, in two years, as I went through the Washington report with Bill Pascoe the other day, will this just seem to be a pendulum swinging back and forth every two years when we want divided government? That's up to you, ultimately, the American people. Now in Shenzhen, China, where this summit took place, and the declaration the White House published,

[00:09:27] we can put that back up on your screen, President Trump meeting with President Putin of Russia for about 40 minutes, then Xi Jinping for about another hour from China there. And then all three sat down together. And here is President Trump opening that three-way meeting. Let's take a look at this. The future is the world's three largest nuclear powers by far.

[00:09:55] The United States, Russia, and China are uniquely positioned to discuss how to reduce the number of nuclear weapons on Earth and also to lessen the risk that those weapons will ever be used. And as we break down everything happening overseas and right back here at home, we'll take a quick break and stick with us here on The Jenny Beth Show. You are the grassroots of America. You love this country.

[00:10:23] When you love something, really love it, the news doesn't just inform you. It fires you up. And you find yourself asking, how can I make a difference? That is exactly what this show is built to answer. Never, ever, ever, ever give up. We owe it to every American who has ever voted to make America great again. We owe it to our future selves. We owe it to this republic to stand tall, to stay active, and to be smart about how we spend our energy so that we can win.

[00:10:53] Here on The Jenny Beth Show, we're going to help you do exactly that. Every show, we will break down the news, connect it to first principles, and give you specific, effective ways to take action. Not just outreach, action. And I am so glad you're here on this journey with us to do it. So let's get to it. Welcome to The Jenny Beth Show. Welcome back to The Jenny Beth Show. I'm Robert McNeely, in for Jenny Beth Martin.

[00:11:21] And we have back with us Phil Kirpin, President of American Commitment. You know, Phil, we're watching President Trump as he was overseas, wrapping up the APEC Summit, the first trilateral meeting between him and Putin and G.G. Penn. Very historical, as today marks the anniversary in 1985 where Reagan met with Gorbachev for the first time. Ultimately, President Reagan meeting with the Premier, Miguel Gorbachev, on five occasions.

[00:11:48] What does America get from sitting at this table? And how can we really weather the storm as history sometimes does not repeat but rhymes itself as we're seeing today? Well, obviously, almost all of our major strategic issues deal with these two countries. And, you know, any kind of breakthrough is probably more likely to come from direct talks and negotiation than almost anything else.

[00:12:14] And Trump has shown that he has a very strong ability to build personal relationships, even with our adversaries, and potentially get some significant concessions. So, you know, these things are tough. You never know if anything will come from them. But, you know, it never hurts to try. Never hurts to try. It's very important to talk to adversaries and friends alike. And we've seen this president really change that strategy compared to his living predecessors, I think, for the better.

[00:12:41] Now, Beijing put out its account claiming President Trump told Xi that the United States does not support Taiwan independence. Now, the White House has not said that. And the declaration it published does not mention Taiwan at all. Why would Beijing put out a line Washington has it confirmed? Is it part of their aggressive strategy to really shape the narrative?

[00:13:08] Well, you know, this is the Taiwan issue is a really interesting issue in that, you know, everyone in the world, including the Taiwanese and the Chinese, understand that Taiwan is functionally independent. It has been for many decades. But everyone sort of agrees not to exactly say so. And Taiwan never declares independence. And we call our embassy there, you know, not an embassy. And we sort of all play these games and these fictions. And, you know, I think that Trump normally doesn't observe these niceties the way most people do.

[00:13:36] And so if you look historically, a lot of his comments kind of don't use the careful wording that we typically get in diplomatic contexts. And I think that the Chinese are probably just underlining that things are still the same way they've always been and not that we're in any kind of new era in terms of recognition of Taiwan. And, you know, I don't know that it has any significance one way or the other in terms of, you know, that they might be planning to do anything or anything about the relationship with the United States.

[00:14:02] But I think they're just kind of repeating what the official line has always been. Yeah, and President Xi breaking that protocol, coming to the red carpet, greeting President Trump and actually giving him a hug. And it's something that's quite interesting to watch on this global scale, as we know that the two largest economies in the world are battling it out peacefully,

[00:14:26] but also so much at stake and the reciprocation being found from his last meeting in Washington, D.C. Now, any treaty to cut nuclear weapons needs 67 senators or two thirds of the Senate. And in January, Democrats, they do run the Senate as much as it makes my blood boil.

[00:14:47] As the Shenzhen Summit comes to an end today, could a denuclearization deal ever get through the table when it comes to the new party in power in the 120th Congress? Probably not. I think it's unlikely that Trump would even submit anything as a formal treaty. I think it's much more likely that any agreement would be informal for the simple reason that, as you pointed out, it's very high bar and treaties almost never get ratified anymore.

[00:15:14] And in fact, you know, we've we've got a few Democratic presidencies recently where every international agreement you can imagine was called everything other than a treaty to avoid submitting to the Senate. So I would be surprised if he pursues the route of an actual official ratification of anything, even if there is an agreement. Yeah. And right now, for people to know, just a scale, the United States and China both respectively have around 4000 warheads each somewhere in that proximity.

[00:15:41] Russia around that six to eight hundred mark. As we see it today, the three largest countries with the three largest stockpiles of those weapons. President Trump says the tariffs were split up in a fair way to quote him and that the trade truce with China runs out in on January 10. So it's 52 days from now. What should American farmers watch for?

[00:16:06] Well, you know, the big question, of course, is whether we're going to see a thawing of trade relations between the U.S. and China if the president feels he's accomplished his objective sufficiently to where he can dial back tariffs from the U.S. side. And if that happens, of course, I would expect the retaliatory tariffs to also be lifted and maybe substantial purchases of U.S. soybeans to begin again. And of course, you know, they made significant commitments, promises in that regard that haven't fully been kept.

[00:16:32] And so, you know, I think the key there are sort of two key things to watch. One is, you know, is there some new agreement or some withdrawal from the from the trade tensions on both sides in terms of what's announced? But then, of course, even more significant is what actually happens, because what's announced isn't from the Chinese side, at least isn't always what actually happened. So, you know, I'll believe it when we actually see the shipments being shipped and the payments being made. President Reagan once said, trust but verify.

[00:17:02] I think we're in the situation now, Phil, of simply verify with our adversaries. If you like this show, The Jenny Beth Show, like, share and subscribe. We need more patriots like you to reach out to constitutional conservatives, to traditional liberals and those who care about this great nation. Now, 250 years young. So be sure again, like, share and subscribe and tell your friends about it. We're joined with Phil Kirpin.

[00:17:30] If you're just tuning in, president of American Commentator. We're excited to have you, Phil, to break down so much happening in Washington, D.C. and abroad. Senator John Cornyn of Texas lost his seat this month. And the Washington Examiner story up on your screen there, he's not from Texas. He hasn't been vetted, to quote Senator John Cornyn, outgoing lame duck. He's refusing to return his blue slip for T. Elliott Gazer.

[00:18:00] He's President Trump's pick for federal judgeship in Dallas, Texas. Now, Cornyn says, as I mentioned, that he's not from Texas. He has not been vetted. But, Phil, a senator is on his way out, and he's stopping the president's judicial nomination. David McIntosh actually took to X, saying that John Cornyn is proving to be an incredibly petty man. What's really going on, and what's your view on this?

[00:18:26] I do think this is just retaliation against President Trump for endorsing against him in the primary. I don't know this judicial nominee personally, but from everything I've heard, he's very well qualified and very conservative, would be a good judge. And more to the point, you know, this is, you know, there's a reason every conservative group is calling on the Senate to clear all of the judicial nominees before the end of this year, which is going to be very, very difficult to get any judges through once the Democrats take power for the next two years. And so, you know, these are lifetime appointments.

[00:18:55] It's a big deal to fill as many vacancies as possible before the end of this year. So unless this man did some truly egregious and outrageous thing that disqualifies him from the federal bench, I think Cornyn is really out of line holding this up. Yes, I would agree. And under the Constitution, judges are appointed by and with the advice and consent of the United States Senate, the entire Senate, in fact. So the blue slip is customary, and the Senate could actually drop it tomorrow. It's not Senate dogma.

[00:19:24] It can actually change. So should Chairman Grassley move Gazer without it? And what do you think about blue slips going forward, Phil? Well, you know, I think it's – I can see both sides of it. I think the argument against it, of course, is, you know, the president won a national election. Part of the powers of the Constitution gives him the power to appoint judicial nominees. On the other hand, we do like to have checks and balances.

[00:19:50] And when the other parties has the presidency, it's nice to have senators have the ability to stop, you know, the more outrageous nominees and to be able to exert that power. And so I can see both sides of it. I think that in this particular instance, though, Cornyn really should relent. It shouldn't be – this issue shouldn't be forced to head over a member of the president's own party holding up a nominee in a lame duck session. That is just insane.

[00:20:15] And so I hope that Cornyn will come to his senses and we won't have to decide this bigger question over this, you know, this episode where it really shouldn't be – this shouldn't be why we need to get rid of blue slips. If we ever decided to do that, it should be because Democrats are blocking nominees, not because someone of your own party is. Yes, I would have to agree with that as well. Leader Thune's numbers are about to come up on the screen here.

[00:20:38] 59 lifetime judges confirmed, four more filed, and he wants a package of about 100 more nominees before January 3rd when the Democrats take power. Can the Senate get 100 nominees through in only 45 days? I think so. Most of them are executive branch nominees that can be packaged together in an on-block vote.

[00:21:02] And so I would expect – you know, you're talking about 100 nominees, but probably 90 of them will be packaged in a single vote, something like that. The bigger question is those judges who have to be voted on individually, and I think there's some 15 or 20 of them that have been nominated by the president. And so, you know, he's filed on four. That leaves another 15 or so, and that needs to be the priority of getting those through. The executive branch nominees, it would be great to get all of them through, but if for some reason one of them doesn't, you can use actings, you can use other things to get around them.

[00:21:31] The most important thing are the judicial nominees because those are lifetime appointments. The Senate also moved the permitting bill. Wednesday's vote to end debate was 65-31, with 14 Democrats saying yes and Republicans Josh Hawley and Mike Rounds voting no on that amendment. Final passage could ultimately come tonight. We'll watch that closely. Steve Molloy wrote that the bill only energizes the Green News scam, to quote Mr. Molloy.

[00:22:01] Phil, is he about to make the right assessment about this legislation? You know, I have really good friends that are on both sides of this bill, and so it's a tough one to parse out. You know, you look at the reforms to EPA permitting that are in there, and they're very, very positive, particularly for clean water act permits, which have held up a lot of valuable projects in this country. And I think the other things in terms of shot clocks and some of the other restrictions, they really are going to be helpful in terms of getting things permitted and moving forward. And that can be hugely positive.

[00:22:29] The American Petroleum Institute is hugely supportive because they think it's going to be very pro-oil and gas. On the other side, it does give new powers to FERC, and it does give FERC the ability to approve distribution lines and to parcel those costs out among the states. And so we may see the socialization of some transmission costs imposed by federal regulators on the states. I don't like that. And the other issue that some conservatives have is that it may pave the way for more offshore wind approvals. And I know that's why Andy Harris from the Freedom Caucus is against this bill.

[00:22:59] So I think there's a lot of good in it, but there's potentially some pretty dangerous provisions here in terms of increasing the power of FERC and moving forward on some of these wind projects that don't make a lot of sense. And so, you know, the president got asked about this, got asked specifically about this issue of is this going to move a lot of wind projects forward? And he said, no, I'm still against those. We're still going to stop those.

[00:23:20] And so, you know, I think on balance, the bill probably will do a lot of positives in terms of moving a lot of projects that we like forward and not getting them caught up in red tape. The question is, and the potential danger is, can we get another Democratic administration come in? Are they going to abuse the new powers that FERC has been given and use that to build lots of transmission lines everywhere and socialize those costs? That would be a big negative. So, you know, I have sort of weighed in.

[00:23:49] I signed on supporting this bill because I think the positives of fixing permitting for all those projects that we want to get done are pretty important in the near term. But I do understand the concerns on the other side. So this is a tough one, Robert. It's not totally obvious which side is right. And I think the House vote is going to be difficult for the simple reason that the Freedom Caucus is against it, you know, for the reasons that I said related to offshore wind. And so unless the Democrats come in with big numbers, it could struggle, especially if they have to bring it up on suspension, which is the two-thirds vote.

[00:24:18] So it's not, you know, the outcome, it remains to be seen. But, you know, it would be important to finally accomplish some of the things we've been talking about in terms of fixing the permitting process that makes it so difficult to build almost anything in this country. So I think the positives are considerable with this, although there are negatives as well. Still a very narrow majority as we're in this lame duck session the next 45 days. Senate Republicans also want a $350 billion defense bill through budget reconciliations.

[00:24:48] The process needs only 51 votes. It's about $1,000 for every person in America. And Leader Thune calls it an open question whether he has the votes. House Republicans say no on the spending cuts, so no deal as of right now. But should conservatives back it if it isn't paid for or just continue to add to the national debt?

[00:25:14] Well, I think it should be paid for, and I think that they need to redo the budget resolution. Robert, they made a big mistake, I think, doing a budget resolution that only has reconciliation instructions for a handful of committees. Basically, their thinking was they can do another super quick, small reconciliation package like they did for the Department of Homeland Security in the beginning of the year. But at this point, this is the only train leaving the station.

[00:25:39] This will be the only exercise in any significant policymaking that occurs if they, in fact, do it. And so I think you can't do just defense. They need to reopen the budget resolution process. They need to add in there a health care title, focus very heavily on waste, fraud, and abuse. That can more than pay for the other things that they want to do in terms of defense and FAA modernization, other things. We can easily pay for it if we do a real crackdown on fraud and abuse, which we know is rampant.

[00:26:06] And I think that we also need to address the debt ceiling in this package because as much as I hate raising the debt ceiling as a conservative, if they don't do it in this package, the Democrats are going to use that as leverage for something we really, really hate next year. And so I think they – I like the idea of doing a reconciliation bill this year before they lose power. But I think that they need to amend the budget resolution, add more committees of jurisdiction. We need to have ways and means and Senate finance in there. And I would put some tax changes in there too.

[00:26:35] We can deliver some things like indexing capital gains for inflation. It can be positive pro-growth things as well. But to me, the key to it, to making it palatable to conservatives is you can't just spend all this money and do nothing to cut spending. And they've done a lot of work on the health care waste, fraud, and abuse stuff. And that stuff is ready if they're willing to take that on, and I think they should. Leader Thune said that on Fox, independent voters broke against us by 30 points.

[00:27:04] And that Republicans have to start delivering an economic message about the cost of living. What does that message ultimately sound like? Because we know that these Democrats are very good at emotional messaging. And it sometimes comes across highly more effective than the Republican side. Yeah, look, I mean, I think we have a winning message. And we had a winning economic situation in 2025. And that's because the incomes are rising much faster than prices, which is the opposite of what was happening under Biden.

[00:27:34] The problem we had in 2026 leading to this wipeout election is that we were back in a situation where prices were rising faster than incomes. And that was almost entirely because of the double supply shock that we had with the crude oil shock in the war in Iran. And then on those already elevated prices, we had the diesel shock with Ukraine striking Russian refineries. When you have a double supply shock like that and the price of diesel goes up dramatically, that's not going to stay contained. Because diesel is an input in everything grown, shipped, and manufactured.

[00:28:03] And what we've seen is we had about six months in a row where prices were rising faster than incomes again. And when you have that situation, you're not going to convince people that actually they're OK, even though people are still much better off than they were when Trump came into office. Because incomes rose very, very strongly in 2025, much faster than prices. And even though we're on kind of a six-month losing streak, people are still much better off than they were a year and a half ago in middle income. But that said, they don't think about it that way.

[00:28:31] They think, can I afford as much for myself and my family this month as I could last month? Or am I falling behind? And if you're falling behind and if it happens month after month after month, you're going to vote for the other party. The irony and the tragedy of this, though, is the other party is worse in every way on affordability. And the Democrats have not promised any particulars that would actually ease the situation, especially with respect to energy. Because you look at the states where they're in charge and prices are much higher than national prices.

[00:28:59] You look at California, for instance, the price of the pump is typically $2 more than the rest of the country. Why? Because the policy choices that they made, the highest tax, reformulated gasoline mandate, low carbon fuel standard, cap and trade. You add those, it's two extra dollars. And so the Democrat agenda is still very hostile to things being affordable, even though they had all the right slogans. And so I think they're going to have a big problem, a big challenge delivering.

[00:29:23] The big question, of course, is the same thing that it has been all year, which is when are these geopolitical situations going to resolve? Because the underlying domestic policies are very pro-energy. We should have very affordable energy, as we did last year, because we've got a huge amount of domestic production. We have regulatory and now potentially permitting policies that are very friendly to oil and gas development and production. And so if we get resolution on the geopolitical situations, we could have a big decline.

[00:29:51] And then, of course, you know, the psychology would totally reverse and people would be happy. But that, I think, is the challenge, much more so than, you know, a messaging thing or talking about it. The one thing I'll say about messaging is I think that Trump and other Republicans should have done a much better job of acknowledging that the gas prices were a huge problem and that they were a consequence of foreign policy decisions, but made the case that it was worth it. And Trump did this a couple of times.

[00:30:17] I remember that you remember that one speech he gave where he said, you know, I know you're paying a lot at the pump and that hurts, but it's worth it to not have a U.S. city nuked by Iran. And then, of course, the media claimed that he wanted those cities nuked and they turned it into another fake scandal thing. But I think much, much more effort to explain that this was both temporary and necessary for foreign policy objectives might have helped. But the bottom line is, you know, everyone drives around. They see those giant numbers everywhere they go.

[00:30:46] And if they're making them angry because it affects their total household budget on a month-by-month basis, there's not a whole lot you can do about it. The other thing, Robert, maybe the Republicans could have done better is just to explain how much worse things are under Democratic policies and in the states where they're in charge and that they can't be your answer. They can't be your solution to this problem of, you know, getting pinched economically.

[00:31:09] But honestly, the problem was more the substantive situation, the price situation, than it was the political messaging. And I think that directly affected the race in Kansas and Roger Marshall losing his seat. I think that had a huge effect there in America's heartland. Now, what's the one thing the Senate has to finish before January 3rd in your assessment, Phil? Well, we already mentioned that they've got to do those judicial nominees. I put that number one just because those are lifetime.

[00:31:38] Those are, you know, that's a big, big deal because I expect those seats will be held vacant most likely by the Senate. I think they're going to take very, very little action on any Trump nominees for the next couple of years. So that is the one absolute must-do. But I'd like to see them do as much legislating as possible for the simple reason that, you know, we're not going to get anything that's directionally helpful in terms of economic growth or any of the other conservative priorities once the Democrats take power. And so, as I said, I would reopen the budget resolution.

[00:32:06] I would add more committees of jurisdiction. I would do another big, beautiful bill, if you will. I would try to fit as much into it as possible and give Trump pieces of legislative authority that he can use to move things forward over the next couple of years without going back to Congress. So I would try to do as much as I can on tax, on health care, on waste, fraud, and abuse.

[00:32:27] And I would try to put, you know, as much as Senate rules will bear into another big reconciliation vehicle, understanding that this is kind of the last hurrah most likely for this presidency in terms of legislation. Now, before we go on, here's your assignment at home. This month's election was a tough night for conservatives. We're still reeling from it, but there's always hope and light at the end of the tunnel.

[00:32:51] Before Tea Party Patriots action decides what comes next, we want to hear from you. So go to teapartypatriots.org. Click on the post-election supporter survey. That's teapartypatriots.org. And it's right there on your screen now. You can pause and do it at this moment or do it in a minute or even when we're off the air.

[00:33:15] But please do so today so we know how to move forward fighting for you, the great American patriots. Phil, let's go to the House now where an amnesty bill is one signature away from a vote. A discharge petition forces this House vote once 218 members sign it, even if the leadership says no.

[00:33:39] Now, the petition for the American Dream and Promise Act, a path to legal status for people brought here illegally as children and for people on temporary protected status, has 217 in its support docket. Every Democrat signed and so did three Republicans, Maria Elvira Salazar of Florida, Brian Fitzpatrick and Don Bacon as well.

[00:34:02] Hakeem Jeffries says we should actually move that bill immediately to quote the potential incoming speaker designate. Phil, where do you see this debate going? This has been one that has literally been two decades or more discussed on this specific legislation. Does it survive in the Senate or does it even reach the president's desk before the new year?

[00:34:28] Well, I think it would be a huge waste of time and energy for Republicans to do any immigration bill in this session. They've got so many priorities in terms of conservative things to move forward. I would say if there's going to be some kind of deal, some grand bargain compromise on immigration, whatever you want to call it, that should be between Trump and the Democrats next year and the Democrats should own it legislatively. I would say, you know, if they can force something through the House with a discharge, I don't think it should be taken up in the Senate.

[00:34:55] I would say, you know, leave that leave that for Schumer and Jeffries to deal with Trump on. And Senator Mike Lee's answer, we could pull up right on the screen. Amnesty never. He's been very clear on this and voters actually agree. As Mike Lee said, amnesty is a betrayal of the entire nation, a promise to pull the rug out from the future generations of American citizens on behalf of citizens of foreign countries. Amnesty never.

[00:35:25] In July of 2025, a McLaughlin and Associates poll commissioned by Tea Party Patriots action found 76.5% of likely voters said illegal immigrants should not get amnesty or even jump the line. That includes 71% of Democrats. So it seems like the vast majority of voters agree on this issue. Why does Congress continue to either provide amnesty or even kick the can down the road?

[00:35:55] Well, I think they're misinterpreting some public opinion that is real on the immigration issue. And that is, you know, people, I think, strongly supported the president when his focus was on securing the border. And when he was so successful at that, it's incredible. You look at, you know, you look at the, you know, we were at some point having over 100,000 illegals per month released by Border Patrol into the United States with a ticket that said, you know, come back in five years or whatever.

[00:36:21] Those releases, the intentional releases by Border Patrol into the United States under Trump have been zero, I think, 18 months in a row. Literally zero, like not a single one after, you know, there were thousands under the previous administration. And so he was extremely successful at the border. I think that was very popular. And I think that the efforts to enforce and deport violent, criminally illegal aliens were also very popular.

[00:36:44] I think where things got dicier and where public opinion got much more mixed is when you had things like workplace raids and where you had efforts to deport people whose only crime was illegal presence in the country. And I think, you know, that is still generally polls will show that's more popular than not. It's, you know, it gets right around 50 percent, but it doesn't get the 70 or 80 percent that those other things do. And it gets much more divisive. And that's where we got protest movements and things like that.

[00:37:08] And so that, I think, is the challenge is, you know, how do you deal with the things that people really, really object to, the total lawlessness, but still, you know, make sure that we have enough workers to meet economic needs, that you're not going to have massive workplace disruption, that you don't have the kinds of activities that become the predicate for people doing these protests and these backlashes and all of the anti-ice activity and so forth.

[00:37:32] And I think that to say that the lesson is we need to just do a blanket amnesty for millions of people, I think is the wrong lesson. I don't think that's accurate at all, but I do think that if you could do some sort of an arrangement where you expand legal guest worker programs or you have a, you know, some kind of a project where people can apply for some sort of permit that can never lead to a path to citizenship and that has other requirements that are onerous on it or whatever it might be, there might be a deal that could be done.

[00:38:01] And the one thing that I think people trust President Trump to work a deal on is this issue. So if the Democrats come to him and they work something with him and it has the key elements that he wants to see in terms of, you know, enforcement and is very tough on criminal illegals in particular, if they could do something to meet the economic needs and to deal with, you know, the more sympathetic people who've been here 20 or 30 years and all this kind of stuff that draws the headlines, you know, maybe there's a deal to be done.

[00:38:28] But I do think it would be a mistake to just say, well, you know, Trump's approach didn't work. So let's go the total opposite direction and the political goal lies in saying, you know, legalize everyone. There's a reason that the Democrats want that and that is they're convinced it's very good for them. So Republicans should be very wary, I think. Well, it's the actual great replacement theory. I think they're really putting people, especially in blue states where they lost a lot of voters.

[00:38:55] The voters have literally been casting ballots with their feet by moving in this great American migration ever since COVID. And I think that has a lot to do with it. And I think two things can be true at once to your point. You know, I think one of the tests, one of the one of the tests of sincerity, I think, for any kind of a grand compromise on immigration is that if we're going to allow people whose only crime is the illegal entry, and otherwise they've been, you know, upstanding, wonderful taxpayers, if we're going to allow them to stay,

[00:39:23] I think there should be a clear prohibition on them ever becoming citizens, on them ever exercising voting rights. And I think if we have that provision in some ironclad way and the Democrats don't recoil from it, that'll tell you that maybe they're sincere. Or if they go crazy, it'll tell you that the actual objective is to change the composition of the electorate. Yeah, I hope Republican leadership is listening. Maybe throw that in as an amendment and see what happens when it comes to a voice vote or a floor vote,

[00:39:51] because I think this very issue, Phil, highly affected not only 2024 with the blue districts on the border going red for the defense of farmers and ranchers who dealt with that violence at the border, but also in 2026 with situations where abuela or abuela or family members of especially Hispanic heritage might have been detained or taken away based upon that illegal entry years and years ago.

[00:40:19] Now here's Homeland Security Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen at Wednesday's House hearing. Let's take a quick look. So as of to date, underneath the Trump administration, we've removed 2,705 terrorists or suspected terrorists that were let in underneath the previous administration, President Biden's administration, and most of them gave, actually all of them gave false names. Secretary Mullen testified that every one of them gave a false name.

[00:40:47] So in 1986, Congress gave amnesty to about 2.7 million people, and the border enforcement it promised never, ever came. Phil, what stops that from ever happening again? Is it what we just discussed, or is there really something comprehensive that can move forward that gets Republicans and Democrats on the same page? You know, the challenge that we've got on this issue, and I think we saw this very clearly in the contrast

[00:41:15] between Trump and then Biden and then Trump again, is that the laws on the books actually matter much less than the will of the party that's in power to enforce them. And, you know, you could write the greatest, strongest border law ever, but if you have a president who doesn't want to enforce it, you're going to have the same situation you had under Biden. And you don't need a new law. You know, we remember all the people under Biden were saying, oh, you know, you need a new law. There's no way to secure the border without a new law. Well, they didn't pass one. And Trump immediately closed the border.

[00:41:44] It was a matter of political will. And so it's very tough. Other than making public opinion strong enough that a Democrat wouldn't want to do what Biden did, I don't know that you can actually constrain, you know, a problem that's fundamentally lawless. You know what I mean? You know, it already was against the law to have a totally open southern border, and yet Biden did it anyway. So a new law doesn't necessarily fix that problem.

[00:42:12] The only way you fix it, I think, is you make it politically untenable for a Democratic administration to do what the last one did. Now we'll tackle the topic of health care because it seems to be on the minds of many Americans. Roald Cal's story is up on the screen, and House Democrats nominated Hakeem Jeffries for Speaker of the House, 251 to 11. I was a bit surprised, actually, by that difference in number.

[00:42:40] I thought the progressives would put up more of a stink with that. But seven of the incoming members who voted no said why in writing. Medicare for all. Stopping ICE terror, getting money out of politics, or even ending the genocide in Gaza to quote some of the DSA members. Now ICE and Immigration and Customs Enforcement, that's what it stands for. Maybe it should be called NICE, National Immigration and Customs Enforcement. We'll see what happens there.

[00:43:07] That very same day, Senator Bernie Sanders made Medicare for all the very first priority of the Senate Health Committee that he takes over in January. A scary thought, Phil. Where does this health care fight move over the next two years? Yeah, I mean, Medicare for all is such a dishonest way to describe, you know, government-run single-payer health care. Because if you look at the Bernie Sanders bill, he calls it the Medicare for all act.

[00:43:35] But if you look inside the bill, it terminates Medicare. It ends Medicare. It ends both Medicare Advantage and traditional Medicare. And everyone in the country goes into this new government-run system. And it makes no difference if you paid Medicare taxes your whole life, or if you paid not one penny, and everyone is treated exactly the same. And in fact, Bernie has a provision in this bill. First of all, it's every resident of the country, not every citizen. So illegals have full access to Bernie's, you know, taxpayer-funded single-payer health care

[00:44:04] exactly on par with legal citizens and with seniors who spent their whole life paying into Medicare, which I think is pretty outrageous. And, you know, the idea that, you know, government- Democrats have this philosophy, or at least socialists like Bernie have this philosophy, that competition and choice is waste, is redundancy, is duplication. And so whereas you and I might think, hey, it's wonderful if you have 10 different hospitals

[00:44:31] and 15 different doctors and you can choose the one that you want to go to based on their reputation, what you hear about them, whether you like them, they have good rapport. Or they think that's waste, that's duplication. We could close nine of the 10 hospitals, just have one, and the government will regulate them and make sure that they do a good job. And we'll save all this money because we're going to get rid of all this duplication. But what happens when you have government-run systems and you don't have competition and choices, they get bureaucratic, they get wasteful, they have no incentive to do a good job.

[00:44:58] And you end up spending a lot more and you get much worse results. And this idea that healthcare is different and special, and therefore it should be run by government, is exactly backwards in my judgment. Healthcare is so important that you really do need to have competition and choice in order to have excellence in order for people to be able to choose providers that actually work for them. And so I think this idea is so dangerous. And you look at the countries that have these single-payer type systems, they all have huge,

[00:45:25] long waiting lists for everything because they don't have those market incentives. They don't have supply that's created to meet demand because of a market-clearing price. And look, our own healthcare system is not great in this regard. It's probably more government than not at this point. But the idea that we should just say, well, let's throw out every private aspect of it and have government take over all of it is exactly the wrong direction to move. And I would much more prefer that we move the opposite direction. We say, look, we're going to have real prices. We're going to have real transparency.

[00:45:55] We're going to bring back choice and competition in healthcare by reversing the consolidation trend where giant health systems and insurance companies have gobbled everything up. We're going to reverse the drivers of that by fixing federal payment policies, fixing tax policies. And we're going to have competition and choice. And you're going to control your healthcare dollars. And you're going to decide where to spend them and have lots of choice. That, I think, would be a winning message for Republicans. They said that some at the end of 2025 when they were fighting Democrats on the expiration of those enhanced Obamacare subsidies. But they didn't deliver on it.

[00:46:25] And I think that's one of the big problems with Republicans on healthcare is they actually say all the right things. They say all the same things that I would say and that probably you would say. But they've just been unable to deliver on it. And of course, we all remember the McCain thumbs down. And so you have this situation where Democrats always seem to have the upper hand on the healthcare issue, even though every time they do something on healthcare, it makes it worse. More expensive, less accessible. But voters think, hey, they're the party that does things on healthcare.

[00:46:52] Republicans are the party that maybe talks about it, but doesn't deliver. And so I would love to see a healthcare title added to an end of the year reconciliation bill. It's probably not going to happen at this point. But if they show they actually care and they're going to pass some things that are directionally helpful, that are going to bring more competition and choice and eliminate the waste and abuse, which is so massive, you know, the CMS under Dr. Oz disqualified 800 hospice providers

[00:47:19] in Los Angeles County, and only 30 of the 800 even disputed the disqualification. 770 of them were like, oh, we got caught. And that was it. They didn't even dispute it, which tells you just how astonishing the scale of fraud and abuse is. And so I would focus on moving healthcare decision-making into more of a market choice competition. You control the healthcare dollars framework. And in the existing government programs, really focus on cracking down on fraud. Don't let Democrats act like everything's great once the government takes over.

[00:47:48] And so we need to have a total government takeover. Because I don't think Bernie's going to get that single payer bill, but they are going to do healthcare bills. And they're all going to move directionally towards where Bernie wants to go by increasing government control regulation and spending, which is going to just turbocharge what we've seen since Obamacare, which is the end of private practice medicine in this country. Everything becoming part of a giant conglomerate.

[00:48:12] I mean, we've already gone from about 20% of doctors having a corporate boss to over 60%. And it's just going to rise even more if you have more government intervention. I think that's been a very bad thing for the quality of healthcare in this country. Yes, I'd like to see something like Senator Ted Cruz's plan from 2016 when he first ran for president resurrected to have this competition again implemented into it because we have a corporatism and too much government involved in our system as it currently stands.

[00:48:41] But here is Sanders laying out his plan and House Majority Whip Tom Emmer's answer on Fox. Let's take a look at this clip. Bill that I have for Medicare for All is a four-year bill. First year, lower the age of eligibility to 55 from 65. Expanded to cover all the children and expanded again to cover dental, hearing, and vision. Next year, it goes down to 45, 35. Everybody is in at the end of four years. All right, the end of four years, everybody's in. How do you pay for it? First, you can't.

[00:49:09] At $47 trillion, when we still aren't addressing the debt that we're carrying, you can't. Medicare at 55 in year one and everybody in by year four. Sounds like socialism to me. Bill, what happens to the health plan people have at work today when you implement something like this? Well, under the Bernie bill, I think that they ban them, at least after the full phase, and that, you know, their private insurance is fully banned and existing Medicare is banned.

[00:49:38] And it's interesting when he says Medicare, you know, and he keeps using the word Medicare. The majority of people on Medicare have Medicare Advantage plans, and they already cover a lot of things that he mentioned there. That's banned. That's banned under this bill. Everyone is just in one government-run plan with no choice in competition. And, you know, I think seniors should be very alarmed by this because we don't have the money to put everyone in this. We don't even really have the money to pay for the Medicare obligations that already exist now,

[00:50:06] which we could do a lot to solve if we did that fraud crackdown. But the dollars don't work. I mean, liberal states have tried this, and they can't make the math work. Vermont repeatedly tried. His own state repeatedly tried to do this and failed and gave up. And so his answer is do it nationally. Now to the meat and potatoes of the entire hour and something that I tuned in for yesterday, Phil. I love your commentary on this. Senator Ron Johnson, chairman of the Senate Budget Committee,

[00:50:35] made headlines Wednesday when he called Social Security a legal Ponzi scheme. His statement can be found right on your screen here. He initially suggested that Social Security cannot be fixed and should be ultimately shut down. But during Wednesday Senate hearing, he clarified all of this. I'm not saying shut down Social Security, to quote the senator from the Badger State. I watched the hearing myself, as I mentioned, Phil, and two things particularly caught my attention here.

[00:51:05] First, Johnson criticized the way Social Security surpluses were handled in the first place, questioning the approach taken during the Reagan-O'Neill negotiations of 1983. He also challenged the idea of the Social Security lockbox, an argument that has figured prominently in political debates, including Al Gore's presidential campaign against George W. Bush in 2000. Second, Johnson made a striking claim,

[00:51:32] had Social Security surpluses beginning in 1986 been invested in a Dow Jones index fund, and Americans could have accumulated approximately $14.5 trillion in assets today, a staggering number. Now it's a hypothetical investment calculation, but it does raise an interesting question about what might have been approached differently under the prior administration of Ronald Reagan.

[00:52:00] Now we're facing another serious Social Security financing challenge. According to 2026 trustees report, the Retirement and Survivors Trust Fund is projected to exhaust its reserves in 2032. So without congressional action, continuing revenue would cover approximately 78% of those scheduled benefits. So Phil, what did Senator Johnson get right about Social Security's financial structure?

[00:52:28] What did he get wrong about the program, and how should we evaluate his $14.5 trillion claim? Well, I think he's basically got everything correct, at least substantively. The big, you know, all of the focus, of course, just goes to the words Ponzi scheme, and that's a semantic debate. You know, that's a question of how you define it. But the math used, the mechanism is the same as in a classic Ponzi scheme,

[00:52:53] which is you keep bringing in new investors and use that to pay your old ones rather than having real returns on investment to cover their returns. And, you know, the semantic debate is about, well, but, you know, Social Security doesn't use fraud. It doesn't deceive people. Everyone can see that that's how it works. And so it's a social insurance scheme, not a Ponzi scheme. Now, that's a semantic distinction maybe, but the math still is the same. Math is still the same. And it's still a really terrible way to run a system like this for the simple reason that demographics do change.

[00:53:22] And you're not going to constantly have a huge supply of new workers that are coming in to cover the retirement benefits of the retirees. And that's why we're in this situation that we're in now. And, you know, the trust fund really was an accounting fiction. You know, because it was required to be invested in government bonds, essentially it just became a ledger entry because it's they, you know, it's invested. They buy the bonds, but then Congress spends that money.

[00:53:49] And so when they go to redeem the bonds, Congress has to come up with the money from somewhere in its budget in order to pay that benefit. And so from a budget, from a cash in, cash out standpoint, you're actually in the same position as if the trust fund had never existed at all. You still need to come up with the money when the Social Security program demands it because the money that was put into the notional trust fund was spent after the bond was purchased. And so the trust fund did not solve the problem in any real economic sense. The trust fund papered it over.

[00:54:18] It was just a ledger entry. It's just an accounting fiction. And so the senator is absolutely correct that we would have been much, much better off if it had been invested in real assets rather than in government treasury bonds that just function as a ledger entry, government owing money to itself. And there are different ways you can calculate it and the exact dollar amount and how much people would have in their accounts. But there's no question that if this had been done decades ago, there would be trillions of dollars sitting in people's personal retirement accounts.

[00:54:46] And they would be able to use those to get much higher benefits in retirement than Social Security promises instead of the debate being over lower benefits. Even if, you know, let's not go all the way back to the 80s, even if it had been done when we had the big debate in 2005, where we still were running substantial cash surpluses in Social Security. And there was a big effort by the White House and there were some other plans from Congress. I like the Ryan Sununu plan personally, which had much larger accounts than the Bush White House plan.

[00:55:13] But, you know, depending on which one of those plans you look at, and we've had the huge run up in stocks since then, people would have millions of dollars. Middle income workers would have millions of dollars in their accounts and they would have much higher benefits rather than lower benefits if we had done that. Now, the problem, of course, is you can could have, would have, should all day long. That doesn't change the fact that we don't have surpluses anymore. And so we don't have the luxury of being able to invest them and generate returns.

[00:55:37] But I think that whatever we do about Social Security, we need to solve this problem on a going forward basis so that there's some element of real investment so that people can get the long term benefits of those returns instead of just counting on, you know, future transfer payments or, you know, future, you know, additional Congress moving money around. Because if we don't do that, eventually they're going to they're going to print the money and we're going to have chronic inflation.

[00:56:06] I don't see any other way unless we somehow go back to having much higher population growth. I don't see any other way to make the math work other than bringing in some element of real investment. And so, you know, that does make the near term problem more challenging because you have to solve the transition problem of, you know, how do you pay the benefits that you can't even afford to pay now at the same time that you're doing investment for the future for younger workers. So it makes a hard problem harder in the near term, but you have to do it.

[00:56:35] Otherwise, you don't have a real solution. And we're going to keep saying, oh, we should have back when. And so whatever they do on Social Security, I think it's critical that they have some element of real investment in real private assets. Yes, it's the perfect storm happening right now with all of those big factors and senators on the other side of the aisle really scaring Americans and going after the chairman to quote them.

[00:57:01] We know that they on the Senate Budget Committee intentionally took Chairman Johnson's Ponzi scheme comments out of context. But the lesson from the 2026 midterm elections, Democrats are good at emotional messaging and that borderlines propaganda at times, but it's effective. So, Phil, how should conservatives talk more about Social Security without scaring people who do depend on it?

[00:57:24] Well, I think they need to make very clear that any changes to the benefits would only be for very high income people that don't need it or that, you know, otherwise have sufficient assets for their retirement. That we're not going to let anyone, we're not going to let any seniors go into poverty in this country. I think everyone's pretty well agreed on that. And I think that they also, and this is where they really should distinguish themselves from the Democrats if they're smart, they say we're not going to do a big tax hike. That's not what the economy needs.

[00:57:52] Walloping small business owners would not be a good quote unquote solution. We need to have strong economic growth to deal with any of the challenges and problems that we face as a society. So, you know, yes, we're open to benefit changes if there need to be benefit changes, but we're not going to do a huge tax increase, which is what the Democrats have been talking about. And I think that if they do that, they can calm some of the fears among regular folks, but also draw a positive distinction that can pay possible political benefits. You serve as president of American Commitment.

[00:58:20] Tell us about your organization and where we can find more of your outstanding work. Thanks. It's a national free market advocacy group. We work on all the fiscal, economic and regulatory issues. And much like you guys do, we do a lot of letter writing into Congress and into regulatory agencies and into governors to try to affect some of these policy fights. And we try to focus on the ones that are on the margin where people can make a difference if they're a little more educated and engaged.

[00:58:45] And so, you know, the big issue that we haven't talked about yet that we've been really focused on is trying to get all the governors to opt into the new scholarship program coming out of the one big, beautiful bill. So it's going to be an incredible opportunity. Starting in 2027, every taxpayer in the country can donate $1,700 single or $3,400 couple to any qualified scholarship granting organization of your choice. And you get it back dollar for dollar on your federal taxes. So if you'd rather give money to a scholarship granting organization than the federal government, you can do that.

[00:59:15] And they're going to be able to raise a lot of money, obviously, with that law in place. And the rub, though, is the way they wrote this for bizarre procedural reasons. The scholarships can only be given out in states where the governor signed up to allow the scholarships to be given out. So no matter what, you can get the tax credit. But you might have to donate to another state's scholarship fund if your governor doesn't want to be part of this, which as of right now, there are 19 governors that have not opted in.

[00:59:44] They're actually 18 that never opted in, and Virginia is trying to undo its opt-in. So there are 19 states that are not participating in this, which is pretty outrageous. So we've been writing a lot of letters to those governors to try to get them to do that before the deadline at the end of the year. Well, I know we'd be happy to help with that letter writing as we did so many postcards over the election because education should be in the hands of students, their parents, and that choice that's very American at its cornerstone.

[01:00:11] Phil Kirpin, thank you so much for all the great work that you do and for joining us and sharing your expertise right here on The Jenny Beth Show. My pleasure. Have a good one. Now, here's that call to action once more. Go to teapartypatriots.org. Click on the post-election supporter survey. Tell us what you think went wrong and what you want us to focus on again for the next two years leading up to the 2028 presidential election. Again, teapartypatriots.org.

[01:00:41] That's teapartypatriots.org. And it's on your screen right now. So please do so today, if not right after this hour. And speaking of this hour on The Jenny Beth Show, if it was useful to you, please hit like and subscribe before you go. And if you want more on those Robert Garcia investigations forthcoming in January, oh, it's give me a migraine. Watch Tuesday's show with Jim Paff, who really breaks it down so well.

[01:01:09] Our dear friend Jim Paff of the Conservative Caucus. Well, let me leave this with you once again. This day in history is November 19th. And as I said at the top of the show, on this day in 1863, Abraham Lincoln stood at Gettysburg and spoke for about two minutes about a government of the people, by the people, for the people.

[01:01:31] It took them as much time to get that famous photo of him just in the nick of time as the speech was anticipated to go much longer. But those two minutes, unforgettable, enshrined upon our memories in history. And on this day as well in 1985, Ronald Reagan sitting down with Miguel Gorbachev for the first time. And he did it from a position of strength, just as President Trump did at the table with Xi Jinping and Putin.

[01:02:01] 45 days, a new Congress takes the gavel in Washington. Lincoln told us who that government answers to, we the people. It answers to you. So keep asking every one of them what they're doing, what law they're writing, who ultimately pays for it as we stand on the shoulders of giants.

[01:02:23] Because on this day as well in 1805, the Lewis and Clark expedition had the first Europeans set sail and across all the way to the Pacific. That included Meriwether Lewis. And William Clark reaching that Pacific Ocean and dating all the way back to 1530. The final decree of the Diet of Augsburg. Charles V signed that. You can find his Bible at the Museum of the Bible in Washington, D.C.

[01:02:52] My favorite new museum when you're in the Beltway. Go and check it out because it really showcases the cornerstone, the foundations of our constitutional republic. And it is that very holy and historical document. So once again, go take that survey today. Only American citizens should decide American elections. I think most America agrees on that. I'm Robert McNeely in for Jenny Beth Martin today. And this is the Jenny Beth show.

[01:03:21] So God bless you and yours. God bless the United States of America. And we'll see you tomorrow. If you enjoyed today's conversation, go ahead and hit like and subscribe. It really helps us reach more people who care about liberty and the Constitution. You can find this and other episodes at JennyBethShow.com, as well as Facebook, YouTube, Rumble, Instagram, X, and your favorite podcast platform. The Jenny Beth Show is hosted by Jenny Beth Martin.

[01:03:48] The Jenny Beth Show is a production of Tea Party Patriots Action. For more information, visit TeaPartyPatriots.org.